“The development of financial assets has reached a critical juncture”, said Michael Heise, Chief Economist at Allianz. “Obviously, extreme monetary policy is losing its impact even on asset prices. As a consequence, an important driver for asset growth no longer exists. At the same time, interest rates continue their remorseless slide, deep into negative territory. For savers, the outlook is not rosy.”
Growth in financial assets in industrial countries slowing
It is certainly no coincidence that slowing growth has hit Europe, the US and Japan the hardest. In Western Europe (3.2 percent) and the US (2.4 percent), growth more than halved in 2015. At the other end of the spectrum is Asia (excl. Japan), where financial assets expanded by 14.8 percent. The region’s lead over the rest of the world is only getting bigger.
This also applies in relation to the world’s other two up-and-coming regions, Latin America and Eastern Europe, where average growth was only half that in Asia. The days in which these regions were able to keep up with their counterparts in Asia are long gone. Of the total global financial assets of EUR 155 trillion, the region Asia (excl. Japan) accounted for 18.5 percent in 2015; this not only means that the proportion of assets held by this region has more than trebled since 2000 but also that the region’s share now far outstrips that of the eurozone (14.2 percent).
South Africa: Asset growth more than halved but liabilities continue to grow steadily
In South Africa, asset growth slowed down markedly from 9.3 percent in 2014 to 3.7 percent last year. After years of bumper growth, 2015 oversaw the smallest increase in wealth since 2008. On the other hand, liabilities climbed by 5.7 percent – slightly faster than last year. Although debt growth has dropped a notch or two after the financial crisis, in the last years it continued to grow steadily and as consequence the debt pile has doubled since 2007. At EUR 2,070, liabilities per capita are today higher than the average of emerging markets (EUR 1,610). Moreover, at 48 percent, South Africa has one of the highest debt ratios (liabilities as percentage of GDP) among emerging markets; in Latin America or Eastern Europe, for example, no country can match South Africa in this regard.
South Africa comes in 39th in the global ranking of net per capita financial assets
With EUR 5,890 net financial assets per capita, South Africa ranked – as in the previous year – 39th in international comparison, behind Mexico but ahead of, for example Russia or Turkey. Compared with the year 2000, however, it has slipped down by three rungs. Besides the long-term frontrunners Switzerland and the US, the list is dominated nowadays by Scandinavian and Asian countries.
Huge regional disparities in debt growth
At 4.5 percent, the liabilities of households grew in 2015 at the same rate as they had in 2014.All in all, household debt came to EUR 38.6 trillion at the end of the year, a good quarter higher than the value prior to the outbreak of the major financial crisis. Developments varied considerably from region to region: In Asia (excl. Japan), debt growth picked up and in some countries like South Korea or Malaysia debt ratios, i.e. household liabilities measured as a percentage of nominal economic output, came in at levels seen in the US, Ireland or Spain at the height of the housing boom. On the other hand, in Latin America and Eastern Europe – due to the crises dogging the major economies in these regions – debt growth has dropped significantly.
In North America and Western Europe, hardly any change was detected, with liabilities increasing at only a very moderate rate – lagging behind the rate of growth in economic output for what is now the sixth year running. So all in all, households – especially in the advanced countries – were still taking a very cautious approach to borrowing; in many countries in Western Europe, liabilities were still being reduced in 2015. “Only very few households seem to succumb to the temptation of ultra-low loan rates and embark on a credit-fueled spending spree”, commented Heise. “The majority of households act in an economically very sensible manner – defying the intentions of central bankers who are trying to pump up demand via aggressive rate cuts. Following the excesses of the financial crisis, however, households view trimming debt as more important.”
As financial assets and debt grew in sync in 2015, net financial assets, too, i.e. the difference between gross financial assets and liabilities, expanded at almost the same rate: they were up by 5.1 percent on a year earlier – clearly below the development in the three previous years when growth figures were in the double-digit region.
Global wealth distribution is getting more equal
The analysis of wealth distribution shows a mixed picture. The success story written by the emerging markets helped more and more people to participate in general progress and prosperity and created a new global middle class; in tandem with this development, poverty levels have dropped significantly across the globe over the past few decades. Although the vast majority of the five billion people living in the countries included in our analysis still belong to the low wealth class, its share is slightly down: today, 69 percent of the total population (as opposed to 80 percent in 2000) belong to this wealth category.
This is because in recent years, more and more people, almost 600 million in total (including some 6 million from South Africans), have achieved promotion to the middle wealth class. The global middle wealth class has grown considerably as a result: in recent years, the number of people has more than doubled to over one billion people; the share of the overall population has climbed from 10 percent to around 20 percent.
The proportion of global assets held by this wealth class has also grown significantly, rising to a good 18 percent at the end of 2015, almost three times the figure at the start of the millennium. So the global middle class has not only been getting bigger in terms of the number of people it encompasses; it has also been getting increasingly richer.
Although there are now fewer households who count among the global high wealth class in the traditional advanced economies, this wealth class has also been growing in recent years: at the end of 2015, around 540 million people across the globe could count themselves among the high wealth class, a good 100 million or 25 percent more than in 2000. This also means that the high wealth class is much more diverse than it was in the past, when it was more or less a club open exclusively to western European, American and Japanese households: these regions and countries now account for 66 percent of the group as a whole, compared with over 90 percent in the past.
The share of global financial assets attributable to this wealth class has also fallen. This development reflects a broader distribution of wealth, at least at global level. “The emergence of a truly global middle class in such a short time span is one of the most important developments for the world economy. To date, this process is being driven primarily by China. If in future more populous countries such as India manage to unleash their potential in full, this success story can continue for the foreseeable future”, commented Heise.
In many industrial countries the middle class is on the retreat
In the national perspective, another story emerges, in particular in the industrial countries. In order to analyze national wealth distribution, this year’s Global Wealth Report investigates the share of total assets held by the middle class and, in particular, how this share has developed over time. No uniform pattern can be identified. In around one third of the countries analyzed, the middle class is shrinking, i.e. the story is one of the gradual emaciation of the middle class, which is participating less and less in overall wealth. Significantly, this trend applies mainly to the euro crisis countries (Italy, Ireland, and Greece) and the traditional industrialized nations (the US, Japan, and the UK). However, as one of the few emerging markets, South Africa also belongs to this group of countries. At the same time, the richest population decile’s share of total wealth has been growing continuously.
In around half of the countries in the analysis, on the other hand, the share of wealth attributable to the middle class has increased: the middle class is gaining ground and, at the same time, wealth is becoming less concentrated at the top, i.e. wealth distribution is becoming more equal. Poland belongs to this group of countries even if the changes are not spectacular. Especially in emerging markets like Turkey, Thailand or Brazil, this development is also associated with an increase in the number of people who belong to the middle class – because they have made the leap up from the low wealth class. Finally, in one fifth of the countries the status of the middle class has hardly changed at all. So, the conclusion is mixed:There are certainly no signs of a general erosion or the decline of the middle class as a global phenomenon – but in many industrial countries this is the case.
The tip of the wealth pyramid is moving further and further away from the average
However, even in places where the middle class is not shrinking,there is no clear-cut answer to the question of wealth distribution as examples such as Switzerland, France or the eurozone as a whole show. Among the three wealth classes, only the middle class is growing. The high wealth class contracted in terms of their share of both the population and net financial assets. However, this does not apply to one particular group within the high wealth class, namely the richest population decile. This group’s share of total wealth has been growing continuously. To sum up: More people are participating in average wealth, while at the same time, the tip of the wealth pyramid is moving further and further away from this average (and is getting smaller and smaller at the same time). Ultimately, this description also applies to the situation across the globe. “The question of distribution is more complex than the catchy headlines referring to rising inequality would like to suggest”, commented Heise. “Policymakers should also differentiate accordingly in the way they deal with the distribution issues facing them. This does not, however, mean there is not an acute need to take action in some countries – particularly the traditional developed countries. The end of a policy of negative interest rates would surely be a good start.”
You can find the study at:
https://www.allianz.com/en/economic_research/ in the Publications/Specials section.
An interactive world map on households’ assets and liabilities can be found here: https://www.allianz.com/en/economic_research
As in previous years, the “Allianz Global Wealth Report” splits asset owners into three global wealth classes. The global wealth middle class encompasses all individuals with net assets of between EUR 7,000 and EUR 42,000.