South Africa unlikely to sort out its debt in four years – Fitch.

Fitch Ratings-London/Hong Kong-26 June: The South African government’s intention to stabilise debt levels within four years, as set out in this week’s emergency budget, is unlikely to be achieved, Fitch Ratings says. This reflects persistent challenges in reducing expenditure, boosting growth and insulating public finances from struggling state-owned enterprises, as well as reflecting the impact of the coronavirus pandemic, which will drive a sharp rise in debt/GDP this year.

Wednesday’s emergency budget revised the consolidated budget deficit projection for the current fiscal year (FY21; ending March 2021) to 15.7% of GDP, over double the 6.8% projected in the original budget in February. The main factor is a sharp fall in tax revenues due to the economic fall-out resulting from lockdown measures, as well as the general hit to the economy and some tax relief. The government expects the main budget revenues to be ZAR300 billion – 6% of GDP – lower than previously anticipated.

South Africa has recorded 100,000 coronavirus cases and this number could rise substantially, according to government modelling. Nevertheless, the government expects non-interest expenditure to be just ZAR36 billion (0.7% of GDP) larger than projected in February, as the emergency budget plans to offset substantial additional spending on health and economic support through savings in other areas.

We view the government’s forecast of gross loan debt rising to 81.8% of GDP in FY21, much higher than the 65.6% in the original budget, as realistic. However, we believe its expectation that debt will peak at 87.4% in FY24 is optimistic. This would require sufficient fiscal consolidation to achieve a primary budget surplus in that year, which would be South Africa’s first since 2008, towards the end of the commodity boom.

The government aims to cut expenditure by ZAR230 billion over FY22 and FY23 relative to earlier plans and then implement additional cuts, complemented by small tax-raising measures. Details will be presented in the Medium-Term Budget Policy Statement in October.

Revenue projections beyond the current fiscal year appear conservative, and revenues may exceed government forecasts (the government predicts that revenues will still be ZAR202 billion below its February projections in FY23). However, Fitch believes planned expenditure cuts seem ambitious not least because they would significantly weaken the economic recovery. South Africa’s recent experience highlights the challenges of meeting fiscal targets. February’s budget abandoned the earlier target for a primary budget balance by FY23 (excluding support for state-owned electricity company Eskom).

Social and political factors, including exceptionally high inequality, powerful trade unions and deep divisions within the governing African National Congress, present significant hurdles for spending cuts. For example, the government has still not agreed the wage bill savings with public sector trade unions for FY21 that were included in the February budget. A comprehensive adjustment of the large public sector wage bill may not be possible until the current three-year agreement expires in April 2021, and negotiations then are likely to be difficult.

Key reforms to Eskom that would support the economy and reduce the burden on the public finances, and relatively minor measures to accelerate GDP growth, have also faced significant political hurdles. Although the challenges in restructuring state-owned flag carrier South African Airways, which filed for business rescue protection last December, are small from a macroeconomic standpoint, they illustrate the difficulty in addressing budget pressures from troubled state-owned enterprises in the face of trade union opposition. Our downgrade of South Africa’s Issuer Default Rating to ‘BB’ on 3 April resulted from the lack of a clear path towards government debt stabilisation as well as the expected impact of the coronavirus pandemic-related shock on public finances and growth. The Outlook on the rating is Negative. A continued rise in government debt/GDP and failure to formulate a clear and credible path towards stabilising the government debt/GDP ratio could lead to negative rating action

Related Content

Africa’s top publisher to close South African publications, cut jobs

JOHANNESBURG (Reuters) - South African media and e-commerce group Naspers plans to lay off more than 500 employees and close a number...

South African rand slides as coronavirus infection rise dims outlook

JOHANNESBURG (Reuters) - South Africa’s rand weakened in early trade on Tuesday as worries over surges in coronavirus infections reactivated investor concerns...

Kibali’s $500 million will be cleared to leave Congo ‘very soon’ – Barrick CEO

JOHANNESBURG (Reuters) - Barrick Gold’s Kibali gold mining joint venture in Democratic Republic of Congo will be able to get $500 million...

AfCFTA: Wamkele Mene on why the free trade deal is Africa’s COVID-19 stimulus plan

The African Continental Free Trade Area promises to be of the biggest economic stimuli for trade on the African continent. But like many projects, it has been hampered by the Covid-19 pandemic. The deal, which aims to boost intra-Africa trade, was launched over a year ago. Commerce was due to start this month; however, it will be implemented in January due to delays. Wamkele Mene, Secretary-General of the African Continental Free Trade Area spoke to CNBC Africa for more....

Subscribe to our newsletter

Sign up for free newsletters and get more CNBC AFRICA delivered to your inbox

More from CNBC Africa

Is the SA govt. doing enough to deter COVID-19 price gouging?

More and more companies, engaging in price gouging, are finding themselves in a spot of bother, as consumers refuse to stand for it. The Competition Tribunal has confirmed three more consent agreements, relating to COVID-19 excessive pricing complaints. Since April, over 20 agreements have been confirmed. Bob Makukunzva, Lawyer at Gwina Attorneys joins CNBC Africa for more.

COMMENT: AfCFTA is economic medicine Africa needs to recover from the covid-19 pandemic

he vast market created by AfCFTA will provide an immediate boon to nascent plans being guided by the African CDC, NEPAD and others to produce various critical healthcare items such as pharmaceutical compounds, PPE and ventilators in countries such as Nigeria, South Africa and Kenya.

More than 70 workers test positive for COVID-19 on an English farm

The number of new confirmed COVID-19 cases across Britain each day has been falling from a peak of more than 6,000 in April to 650 in the latest figures released on Sunday, despite wider availability of testing.

African born tycoon Elon Musk Tesla slashes prices as pandemic weighs heavily

The company headed by Elon Musk this month posted a smaller-than-expected fall in car deliveries in the second quarter, resilient results despite the pandemic that hit the global auto industry.

Partner Content

Tata International concludes a securitization transaction for its African Subsidiaries

UAE financial centers act as a gateway to benefit African businesses GCC, July 13th, 2020: Tata International Limited (TIL)...

Uber launches its largest region-wide initiative in partnership with Mastercard

Uber, in partnership with Mastercard to provide 120,000 free trips to frontline workers in MEA, including South Africa, Nigeria, Kenya, Ivory Coast...

Trending Now

Zindzi Mandela dies aged 59

Zindzi Mandela - the daughter of Nelson and Winnie Mandela - died in the early hours of July 13 in a Johannesburg...

South African rand firms as dollar wobble lifts emerging currencies

JOHANNESBURG (Reuters) - South Africa’s rand firmed early on Monday, helped by increased risk appetite as investors bet again on a global...

Zindzi Mandela, daughter of Nelson Mandela, has died – ANC spokesman

JOHANNESBURG (Reuters) - Zindzi Mandela, daughter of former South African president and liberation hero Nelson Mandela, has died, the spokesman of the...

What lies ahead for the COVID-19 hit journalism industry?

The people who bring us the unfettered truth are becoming thinner and thinner on the ground. In these days of COVID-19 journalist jobs are disappearing faster than most. Ten years ago there were 10,000 journalists in South Africa. In March this year there were 5,000. In the last three months that number has dwindled to just 2,500, according to the South African National Editor's Forum. What next? Hopewell Radebe, Journalist with SANEF joins CNBC Africa for more.
- Advertisement -