‘With inflation falling and growth collapsing it is time to cut interest rates’

The SA economy is in recession – two quarters of consecutive declines in the real distributable pie. The only bright spots are agriculture, which is largely rainfall-dependent, and mining, which is largely commodity price-dependent. These two sectors cannot be directly helped by monetary policy, insofar as interest rates are concerned.

All three rating agencies have made it clear that they would view a weaker growth outlook very negatively.  If South Africa is serious about avoiding further downgrades, the key areas that need to be addressed are the growth outlook and the growing concerns about “institutional quality”. The Reserve Bank can also do little about long-term growth.  That is the job of the rest of government.  Currently the commitment of the broader cabinet to boosting South Africa’s structural growth rate is unclear.  For example, the revised Mining Charter released last Friday will stunt growth in the mining sector for years to come as the industry battles the government in court.

While confidence is lacking at present, the Reserve Bank does have an ability to influence growth in the shorter term, even if it is only cyclically and at the margin.  Given the weakness of growth, this is an important consideration to escape the negative spiral.

The SARB’s mandate is to target inflation.  This mandate has proven to be far more successful and transparent than any rule the SARB has followed historically.  Since 2001, the data shows that the Bank has targeted 5.75% – just below their 6% ceiling.   With inflation falling sharply, there is growing scope to cut interest rates as the year progresses.

The SARB appears averse to such action.  The Bank is concerned about the outlook for the rand.  The May MPC statement noted that “the risks to the inflation outlook, will be highly sensitive to unfolding domestic political uncertainty.”  As a result, the Bank is opting to remain hawkish.

Why would easier monetary policy, which is focused on getting the policy settings right in an economy be seen as negative? The combination of a strong currency and high real interest rates is clearly negatively impacting on growth.

The May MPC statement went on to say that they believe “the current level of the repo rate is appropriate for now…..A reduction in rates would be possible should inflation continue to surprise on the downside.”

The data for both growth and prices show that policy settings are too tight.   The result is hot money inflows chasing high interest rate differentials, a stronger rand and ultimately poor economic growth. Disinflation in the economy is undermining profits, hurting wage growth and curbing investments.

Lower interest rates will reduce the incentive for hot money to flow into the local markets. Is the Reserve Bank worrying too much on flows reversing? If SA gets downgraded by both Moody’s and S&P, we expect ZAR120bn to flow out as South Africa is ejected from the WIGBI.  However, will it?  Barclays sold Absa shares worth R36bn at the beginning of June, and the currency didn’t flinch. Setting interest rates on a forecast of the rand(om) is questionable.

An economy that sees cash in the bank producing the best investment returns compared to other investments is indicative of an economy which has overly discouraged both investment and risk-taking entrepreneurial activity. Households have further been squeezed by too high interest rates at a time when tax rates are also rising, further reducing consumption expenditure.

Many economies in the developed world are stagnant. They have no levers to pull to influence economic outcomes with interest rates at or below inflation. SA is not in this position.

We see this as a time for the SARB to take the lead and make a bold, but correct step looking forward. Changes in policy impact the economy 18 months in the future. If inflation is at 4% by year end, why would short-term rates at 6% be incorrect? That is 100bp lower than today. 2% in real terms is still a lot tighter than most peers.  Given the current political uncertainty, 100bps is potentially wishful.  However, rate cuts of 25-50bps before December look very plausible.

It is important we highlight here that we are proposing rate cuts within the current mandate of the SA Reserve Bank.  We see no need to change the mandate or Section 224 of the Constitution, which governs the objectives of the Bank.  Rather the opportunity to cut interest rates is greatly premised on the strength of the Reserve Bank’s credibility.  The vehicle charting the trajectory to lower interest rates should not be hijacked by politics.

The SARB is internationally viewed as amongst the strongest institutions in South Africa, with the quality of financial sector regulation regarded as being viewed as world class.  The Public Protector’s proposed change would remove the need for the SARB to protect “the value of the currency in the interest of balanced and sustainable growth in the Republic.”  In addition, the Bank would be required to liaise with parliament to “achieve meaningful socio-economic transformation.”

The wording in the Constitution was carefully chosen.  It limits the SARB’s ability to monetise government debt by printing money.  Thus it protects the value of the currency in the Republic, protecting the purchasing power of the rand for the average wage earner.  It protects South Africa from a return to the inflation rates of the late 1980s.  Or from the many currency crises that Zimbabwe, Argentina and Italy (pre-euro) have faced.

With seemingly innocuous changes, Busisiwe Mkhwebane has raised concerns about the inviolability of the independence of the SARB.  Her ability to achieve the proposed changes is highly questionable – Does the Public Protector have the authority to direct parliament to make constitutional changes?  However, her actions may make MPC members more cautious about supporting rate cuts.  We think this would be a mistake.

Despite the unnecessary discussions the public protector has sparked, the palpable threat to the independence of the SARB is limited.  Therefore we would hope that the MPC is able to look beyond these machinations – and focus on their mandate.  Inflation is falling, growth is collapsing.  It is time to cut interest rates.

While the SARB may be tempted to be overly cautious at this time, we think that would be a mistake.  Rate cuts at this point will provide some much needed relief to the SA economy.  Keeping the SA economy out of stall speed is vital to prevent the threat of further populism down the line.

Related Content

How to grow a fortune in the golden fields of Africa.

While smallholder farmers remain an important grouping, it is one that is typically overlooked by many financial institutions. Many have tried to crack this market but have been unsuccessful.

COVID-19: SA’s Q1 GDP decreases by 2%

South Africa’s GDP for the first quarter of 2020 decreased by 2 per cent. The two biggest negative contributors to growth in GDP for the first quarter were the mining and manufacturing industries. Isaah Mhlanga, Chief Economist at Alexander Forbes joins CNBC Africa for more.

UK economy shows biggest drop in 40 years in early 2020

Prime Minister Boris Johnson will set out his plan to speed up the British economy’s recovery later on Tuesday when he will promise to fast-track 5 billion pounds ($6.13 billion) of infrastructure investment.

The Day After COVID-19: Overcoming the Novel Coronavirus double jeopardy in Central Africa

Amidst the suffering and the havoc caused by COVID-19, we witnessed the best of mankind. Former enemies forgot old quarrels and came together for the common good, some sanctions were waived for humanitarian reasons and fighting stopped temporarily.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Sign up for free newsletters and get more CNBC AFRICA delivered to your inbox

More from CNBC Africa

African born Billionaire Elon Musk’s net worth zooms past Warren Buffett’s

The blistering rally also puts Musk in reach of a payday potentially worth $1.8 billion, his second jackpot from the electric car maker in about two months.

U.S. sets record for new COVID cases third day in a row at over 69,000

“If we don’t adopt this best practice it could lead to a shutdown of business,” the Republican governor told local KLBK-TV in Lubbock, adding it was the last thing he wanted.

South Africa set to make SAA funding commitment, official says

JOHANNESBURG (Reuters) - The South African government is “on course” to provide a funding commitment for the restructuring of loss-making South African...

Akinwumi Adesina pays tribute to Prime Minister Amadou Gon Coulibaly

A humble man. A selfless man. A faithful man. A shining light. We met and spoke together on several forums around the world: on the plane, at airports, in high level forums and summits. My impression of him was the same: calm; wise; insightful. A man of few words, whose every word was always well honed for impact. He spoke always from his heart. An he had a heart of gold.

Partner Content

Maktech’s Godwin Makyao: Now Is A Time of Entrepreneurial Opportunity in East Africa

As an executive decision-maker in both the telecommunications and tourism industries, Godwin Makyao could not have experienced a more diverse set of...

Sanlam launches urgent job-preservation initiative in response to COVID-19

Sanlam Investments is responding to the COVID-19 pandemic through large-scale support of the recovery of South African companies, from small enterprises to...

Trending Now

Congo justice minister resigns after judicial reform dispute

KINSHASA (Reuters) - The Democratic Republic of Congo’s Justice Minister Celestin Tunda tendered his resignation on Saturday in the wake of a...

Veteran Zimbabwe farmer pours cold water on $58 million mission from Belarus with love.

“Belarus tractors have never been known for their quality or power. They were never bought by Zimbabwe farmers in the past. Training up 1000 Zimbabwe farmers isn’t the answer.

Congo central bank keeps 2020 economic growth forecast at -2.4%

(Reuters) - The Democratic Republic of Congo’s central bank kept its 2020 economic growth forecast unchanged at -2.4% because of the uncertainty...

South Africa’s rand recovers but caution remains, stocks slip

JOHANNESBURG (Reuters) - South Africa’s rand recovered in afternoon trade on Friday, after sliding earlier due to concerns about rising COVID-19 cases...
- Advertisement -