Share
What Citibank’s economist thinks of ANC’s R73.5bn state funding wish
The ANC has plans which are worth well over R70 billion in the pipeline and South Africa's minister of finance, Enoch Godongwana, responded with hesitation. According to a Bloomberg report, this state spending budget will require difficult trade offs but where will the money come from? Citibank Economist, Gina Schoeman joins CNBC Africa for more.
Tue, 14 Sep 2021 16:41:12 GMT
Disclaimer: The following content is generated automatically by a GPT AI and may not be accurate. To verify the details, please watch the video
AI Generated Summary
- The ANC's proposed budget of over 73 billion rand raises concerns about funding sources
- South Africa faces a fiscal dilemma as it grapples with unplanned expenditures amidst limited resources
- The upcoming mid-term budget statement will shed light on the government's financial priorities and challenges
In a recent report by Bloomberg, it was revealed that the African National Congress (ANC) has proposed an expenditure of over 73 billion rand, causing concern about the source of funding. The report, presented at an ANC meeting by the new Finance Minister Inak Kodomwane, highlighted various areas where additional spending would be needed, including funding for provinces struggling to pay their bills. Citibank Economist, Gina Schoeman, shed light on the implications of this proposed budget and the challenges it poses for South Africa's fiscal health.
The additional expenditure outlined in the report includes measures that have already been implemented, such as the fiscal package announced in July and wage increases following negotiations. However, the significant amount allocated to provinces facing financial difficulties, amounting to as much as 16 billion rand, raises questions about where the funding will come from. With limited borrowing capacity and strained revenue sources, South Africa is left with few options but to find a way to accommodate this additional spending within the existing budget.
Schoeman highlighted that the upcoming mid-term budget statement, scheduled for November 2nd, will be crucial in revealing how the government plans to finance these new expenditures. Despite initial projections of a substantial revenue surplus due to favorable commodity prices, much of these gains now seem destined to cover the unplanned expenses. This presents a challenging dilemma for the government, as it grapples with the need to address inefficiencies in public spending while also responding to pressing funding requirements.
Finance Minister Godongwana's approach to managing the budget reflects a commitment to maintaining fiscal discipline inherited from his predecessor, Tito Mboweni. While signaling a need to reprioritize spending to accommodate the new proposals, Godongwana's stance underscores the government's struggle to balance competing financial demands. The tension between fiscal consolidation and expanding expenditures underscores the broader challenge of navigating South Africa's complex economic landscape.
One of the underlying concerns raised by the proposed budget is the potential influence of upcoming local government elections on spending decisions. Schoeman discussed the complexities of distinguishing between necessary social support measures and populist electioneering, pointing to the deep-seated economic inequalities that drive many of these spending imperatives. While acknowledging the proximity of the elections as a factor, she emphasized the long-standing structural issues that underpin the need for enhanced social assistance programs.
The allocation of 16 billion rand towards addressing SCOM's financial challenges was noted as a positive development, albeit one that underscores the need for systemic reforms rather than short-term financial injections. Schoeman cautioned against viewing such budgetary allocations as permanent solutions, highlighting the imperative for clear policy direction and decision-making to address the root causes of financial instabilities.
The impending mid-term budget statement presents an opportunity for the government to provide clarity on key policy decisions, including the potential introduction of a basic income grant, restructuring of state-owned entities like SCOM, and addressing public sector wage negotiations. These critical issues will shape the economic landscape in 2022 and beyond, providing insights into the government's commitment to sustainable financial management.
As South Africa navigates the complexities of its fiscal challenges, stakeholders will closely monitor the government's budgetary decisions and their implications for the country's economic future. With mounting pressures to address growing expenditure demands amidst constrained revenue sources, the road ahead remains uncertain. The delicate balance between meeting immediate spending needs and broader fiscal sustainability goals will test the government's ability to steer the economy towards long-term prosperity.
SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER
DAILY UPDATE
Get the best of CNBC Africa sent straight to your inbox with breaking business news, insights and updates from experts across the continent.
Get this delivered to your inbox, and more info about about our products and services. By signing up for newsletters, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.