Op-Ed: South Africa sacrifices peace, justice, and good governance to SOEs

The trend worldwide is for wealthier countries to have large governments. South Africa has a government larger than expected and still growing steadily. The international trend for poorer countries is to have many State Owned Enterprises (SOEs), and government investment a larger fraction of the total. South Africa has more SOEs and government investment than is normal for a country at our level of development.

A recent assessment reported no fewer than 717 SOEs in South Africa with total assets of R1 trillion, or 27% of GDP, and government investment amounting to more than 30% of our total investment.

As can be seen from South Africa’s Tax Freedom Day*, which this year falls on May 25, same as last year but six weeks later than in 1994 and a full 2 months later than 1972, SOEs are a substantial burden on the taxpayer and economy.

Orthodox economics says that return on investment in government is lower than in the private sector because, in an SOE, the incentives of stakeholders and the associated bureaucracy, as well as the lack of competition, do not encourage efficiency or innovation. Our government has admitted as much. In its report on SOEs, it stated that, over the five years up to 2014/15, the return on investment in SOEs had declined to a low 2.9%.  Shifting resource allocation from private enterprise to government slows down growth which, long term, adversely affects welfare.  A 2%, rather than a 1%, per capita growth rate, over 70 years, would result in double the relative welfare

Some SOEs are so inefficient that they make large and/or persistent losses. An obvious example is SAA, which has cost treasury more than R35-billion in bailouts since 2007. Government says it has no plans to get rid of or to privatise SAA even though there is no good reason to keep it. The purpose of an SOE is not to create jobs, but to supply a valued public service. Employing almost as many people, private companies competing for air routes and customers could supply a far better service without making a loss (at least not one for tax payers to bear). The same applies to all of the other SOEs.

Bad as it is, SAA is not nearly the largest loss maker among South Africa’s SOEs. In 2014/2015, five SOEs managed to lose R20.6-billion or 2% of government revenue. It may not sound like much, but it would have been enough to roughly double the rate of housing delivery – not to mention the thousands of building jobs that this would entail.

No matter whether SOEs are profitable or not, they create a direct drag on the rest of the economy through being protected from competition, and an indirect drag by being a large, wasteful fraction of the economy. Protecting inefficient enterprises, or shoring them up, slows the growth of productivity and reduces the number of sustainable jobs that would result from a growing economy.

To sum up, SOEs are unnecessary for welfare and employment; inefficient or downright wasteful enterprises; a drag on the economy; create major opportunity costs; expose the treasury to significant risk and the country to bad investment ratings.

Another area where the South African government underperforms is in keeping peace and providing justice and good governance, i.e. rule of law.  Government has no business doing anything unless it has provided for adequate rule of law.  Providing a sound justice system is costly and there is a tight relationship between government consumption and good law indices.  Nevertheless governments do vary in how much they spend to provide a given level of rule of law.  By international standards, and the current level of government consumption, rule of law in South Africa falls short by 26-27%.  Alternatively, given our current state of rule of law, government consumption is 26-27% too high, and, arguably, we need a much better justice system than is being provided for.

By any reasonable standard, South Africa has far too many of SOEs and far too little rule of law.  To invest in better rule of law without increasing the tax load to higher growth sapping levels, we need to end wasteful and unnecessary SOEs.

* Tax Freedom Day (TFD) is the day after which South Africans have worked enough days to pay their taxes. Tax Freedom Day is calculated by dividing general government revenue by GDP for a calendar year, applying this fraction to the number of days in a year, and adding a day. TFD 2017 falls on May 25.


Author: Garth Zietsman is a statistician and consultant.

Related Content

The cost of xenophobic attacks on businesses in Africa

Following the spate of xenophobic attacks in South Africa, many businesses with African operations have been affected as property and stock has been damaged and violence against employees has resulted in death. The South African Chamber of Commerce and Industry has called on business leaders and the police top brass to find a solution to the ongoing violence against other Africans in South Africa. CNBC Africa's Kopano Gumbi spoke with SACCI CEO, Alan Mikoki for more.

World Economic Forum: Minister Pravin Gordhan on the future of SOEs in SA

CNBC Africa's Fifi Peters spoke with the Public Enterprises Minister Pravin Gordhan on the future of state owned enterprises in South Africa.

Obafemi Hamzat on how technology can enhance the rule of law in Nigeria

The Deputy Governor of Lagos state, Obafemi Hamzat says as litigation gains ground in Nigeria, the country must embrace technology, and respect the rule of law. From the sidelines of the 59th Annual General Conference of the Nigerian Bar Association, Obafemi Hamzat joins CNBC Africa's Esther Awoniyi for more.

NBA Conference: Seni Adio on significance of event, fundamental issues and high level government dignitaries in attendance

Seni Adio, Chairman of the Nigerian Bar Association (NBA) Section on Business Law says the Association's 59th annual Conference will focus on the rule of law, Nigeria’s electoral process and more. Adio joins CNBC Africa’s Christy Cole for more.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Sign up for free newsletters and get more CNBC AFRICA delivered to your inbox

More from CNBC Africa

How COVID-19 impacts the health & well-being of children

Research shows that children have a lower rate of contracting the Coronavirus and bringing infections to the household. This should provide comfort to South African parents that are in two minds about sending their kids back to school next week, when physical teaching is set to resume. Epidemiologist, Dr Boshoff Steenekamp joins CNBC Africa for more.

Rebosis rolls out COVID-19 testing stations outside malls

Property Group Rebosis, has partnered with government to roll out testing stations for Covid-19 outside its shopping malls in Pretoria – South Africa’s capital. However, foot traffic into these malls is expected to have dived due to the virus lock-downs prevented non-essential stores from trading. Rebosis is yet to release its interim results. Rebosis CEO Sisa Ngebulana joins CNBC Africa for more.

Distell CEO: What the sale of alcohol under level 3 means for the industry

South Africans can look forward to popping their favourite bottle of bubbly or sipping on a glass of pinotage to warm up from the cold winter. That’s as alcohol sales, that were banned for over two months under the Covid-19 lock-down, will be lifted. Distell CEO Richard Rushton joins CNBC Africa for more.

This Rwandan publisher is creating buzz with new book App

After realising the challenges that come with publishing fellow African writers, home-grown publishing house, Imagine We Rwanda launched their very own mobile app, dubbed, Imagine Books. Fast forward 2 weeks and hundreds of titles have been purchased worldwide and the numbers are only going up. CNBC Africa spoke to the founder, Dominique Alonga for more.

Partner Content

VIVO CEO is a dynamic leader for this innovative global brand

May 2020 -- Six months ago the vision for vivo in South Africa was just beginning to...

Building Africa’s Biggest Digital Classroom

An enduring lesson learnt throughout our 175-year existence is that, while things rapidly change around us, the things that truly matter don’t!...

Trending Now

What Happens To Frequent Flyer Miles If An Airline Goes Bankrupt?

With U.S. passenger traffic down by 90%, airlines are desperate to fill seats and are offering big incentives to keep their most reliable customers loyal. But what happens to frequent flyer miles when almost no one is flying and can an airline loyalt

How The Medical Device Supply Chain Failed During Covid-19

More than three months into the coronavirus pandemic, health-care workers on the front-lines of the battle against Covid-19 say they still face shortages of personal protective equipment. The personal protective shortage was one of the early flashpoi

Tsogo Sun Hotels FY profits plunge, COVID-19 lock-downs weigh

Hospitality Group Tsogo Sun Hotels reported a 31 per cent plunge in full year headline earnings per share, with Covid-19 resulting in demand from international tourist retracting in the fourth quarter, due to global lock-downs.

Nampak swings into H1 loss, suffers R3bn impairment

Nampak swung to a half year loss of R2.4 billion as revenue plunged and it impaired its Angola and Nigeria assets by R3 billion, which is four times its market value. The also warned that future profits were in South Africa were at risk from the ban on alcohol sales due to Covid-19 lock-downs. Nampak CEO, Erik Smuts joins CNBC Africa for more.
- Advertisement -