S.Africa’s land expropriation unlikely to end like Zimbabwe

By Ed Stoddard

President Jacob Zuma’s pledge to expropriate South African land is unlikely to lead to violent seizures of farms like those that impoverished neighbouring Zimbabwe, but could still hurt the economy by scaring off investors worried about property rights.

Zuma is fighting to retain control of South Africa against opponents within the ruling African National Congress who want him to resign the party leadership.


The confrontation came to a head last week when Zuma sacked Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan, who was often at odds with the president but widely respected by financial markets and whose dismissal triggered a credit downgrade.

Faced with opposition mainly from urban constituencies within the ANC, the president has doubled down on appeals to the rural poor, renewing promises to change the constitution to expropriate land without compensation and redistribute it.

“You can’t have a constitution that keeps people in poverty,” he told traditional leaders last week.

Zuma has reminded the party that “expropriation without compensation” was adopted as official policy at the ANC’s 2012 conference.

More than two decades after the end of apartheid rule, most of South Africa’s land is still in the hands of minority whites. Zuma’s ruling ANC has long been committed to the principle of redistributing it.

But the pace has been slow, relying mostly on a “willing buyer, willing seller” policy intended to respect property rights seen as vital to sustaining Africa’s most industrialised economy.

South Africa has many safeguards that should prevent the sort of lawlessness and violence that took place when followers of Zimbabwean President Robert Mugabe stormed onto white-owned farms in the early 2000s.

Zuma himself has said South Africa will not embark on the kind of lawless land grabs that saw Zimbabwe slide from breadbasket to basket case. Unlike Zimbabwe, South Africa has a robust, independent judiciary to keep the government in line.

Nor is South Africa as dependent on farming for its income as its northern neighbour: agriculture accounts only for about two percent of gross domestic product.

But the threat to redistribute land could still harm a sector which is a major employer and feeds a drought-prone nation, and any move to curb property rights could have wider economic repercussions by alarming investors in other sectors.


Changing the constitution as Zuma says he intends would not be easy, with the ANC so sharply divided over his leadership.

“The checks and balances in South Africa and the waning political support for the ANC itself make it difficult to disregard or change the constitution,” said Daniel Silke, the director of Political Futures Consultancy. “We are in a very different space to what was a very autocratic Zimbabwe.”

Zuma’s political woes, including electoral setbacks in major urban centres in local elections last year, explain his populist approach to the land issue.

It is part of a “radical economic transformation” drive aimed at the ANC’s increasingly rural support base. His plans will be high on the agenda of a major party policy conference in June-July, and another in December when Zuma’s successor as ANC leader is to be picked ahead of a general election in 2019.

“Deploying populist rhetoric is a powerful campaign strategy that has worked for Zuma before,” said Ruth Bookbinder, Africa Analyst at risk consultancy Verisk Maplecroft.

The Department of Rural Development and Land Reform says only 8 million hectares of arable land has been transferred to black people since 1994, less than 10 percent of the 82 million hectares available and a third of the ANC’s 30 percent target.

Yet the ANC has not yet fallen into line behind Zuma’s call for constitutional change. In February, ANC MPs voted down a motion by the ultra-left Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) party to amend the constitution to take land without compensation.


Zuma’s bid for rural support has parallels with Zimbabwe in 2000, when Mugabe, then in power for two decades, faced a challenge from an opposition rooted in the urban trade union movement.

Mugabe responded by unleashing violent invasions of white-owned farms that proved devastating to an economy already in meltdown, with acute balance of payments pressures, raging inflation, slowing growth, a depreciating currency and a dependency for funding on the International Monetary Fund.

Zuma too faces challenges from urban quarters, including calls for him to resign from the South African Communist Party and labour federation Cosatu, both allies of the ANC.

The economy is barely growing, the rand currency is vulnerable, inflation could reignite, and further ratings downgrades could push South Africa into the IMF’s embrace, which would see it forced to adopt austerity measures that ANC populists would baulk at.

Damaging South Africa’s high-tech agriculture sector through land seizures could have far-reaching consequences. Wandile Sihlobo, an economist at the agricultural business chamber, told Reuters he reckons the debt book for commercial agriculture is around 160 billion rand ($11.6 billion).

Food security is a concern as South Africa recovers from a drought, with forecasts showing another potentially looming.

Some analysts say such consequences will not dissuade Zuma.

“Zuma has shown he can be absolutely reckless in pursuit of his political agenda,” said NKC African Economics political analyst Gary van Staden.

($1 = 13.7680 rand)

(Editing by James Macharia and Peter Graff)

Related Content

Why Kenya’s recent cabinet reshuffle is a boost for economy

It's only Wednesday but this week Kenya has already seen quite a few big headlines, from yesterday’s cabinet reshuffle, to the preparation of a bailout for the country's national carrier, to a new tax on milk from neighbouring countries. Journalist, Joseph Bonyo joins CNBC Africa for more.

Zimbabwe embarks on anti-sanctions crusade

Zimbabwe is on a public holiday today as the country embarks on a nationwide strike for the removal of sanction imposed by the United States. The U.S sanctions target those who engage in corruption, human rights violations and those who undermine democratic processes. Gauteng ANC Provincial secretary Jacob Khawe and ZANU PF South Africa Spokesperson Kennedy Mandaza spoke to CNBC Africa about the impact of sanctions on Zimbabwe.

ANC’s NEC outlines turnaround plans for SA’s ailing economy

The ANC NEC gathered at Luthuli house earlier to discuss plans to deal with South Africa's ailing economy based on a meeting they had over the weekend. The restructuring of state-owned enterprises, attacks on foreign nationals and gender-based violence was top priority. CNBC Africa’s Yolanda Mabanga filed this report.

‘An inspiration that stood the test of time’: A reflection on Dr. Thandi Ndlovu’s life

‘Feisty And Fearless Pioneers’ – that was the Forbes Africa August cover with Nonkululeko Gobodo and that now late Dr. Thandi Ndlovu. Tributes continue to stream in following the car accident that led to the passing of a former medical doctor, member of Umkhonto we Sizwe (ANC's military wing), former President of the Black Business Council, & Founder of Motheo Construction, Thandi Ndlovu. To reflect on the life and work of Dr. Thandi Ndlovu, Managing Partner of Brighton Wealth SubSaharan, Kunyalala Maphisa joins CNBC Africa for more.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Sign up for free newsletters and get more CNBC AFRICA delivered to your inbox

More from CNBC Africa

Chinese factories to face headwinds in next phase of post-lockdown recovery

The rosy outlook stands in stark contrast to the dismal industrial landscapes of other economies still fighting COVID-19. Factory output plunged further in May from a year earlier in Japan, South Korea and the United States. Euro zone manufacturing output fell by a record 28% in April.

WHO acknowledges ‘evidence emerging’ of airborne spread of COVID-19

But in an open letter to the Geneva-based agency, published on Monday in the Clinical Infectious Diseases journal, 239 scientists in 32 countries outlined evidence that they say shows floating virus particles can infect people who breathe them in.

Zimbabwe’s health minister, accused of corruption, sacked: statement

HARARE (Reuters) - Zimbabwe’s President Emmerson Mnangagwa has sacked health minister Obadiah Moyo with immediate effect for inappropriate conduct, a statement from...

Senegal slave island, moved by George Floyd’s death, renames Europe Square

“But we also said to ourselves...that in another sense it is celebrating the persecutor,” he said. “What happened to George Floyd was the final straw.”

Partner Content

Maktech’s Godwin Makyao: Now Is A Time of Entrepreneurial Opportunity in East Africa

As an executive decision-maker in both the telecommunications and tourism industries, Godwin Makyao could not have experienced a more diverse set of...

Sanlam launches urgent job-preservation initiative in response to COVID-19

Sanlam Investments is responding to the COVID-19 pandemic through large-scale support of the recovery of South African companies, from small enterprises to...

Trending Now

Implement substantive reforms, Paris Club creditors tell Zimbabwe

HARARE (Reuters) - Zimbabwe should implement sustainable political and economic reforms and successfully complete an IMF monitoring programme in order to normalise...

COVID-19 lock-down: How the Gauteng government plans to safely reopen schools

Since the gradual opening of the economy after lock-down there has been a sharp incline of COVID-19 cases. The government has the task of balancing the health of the people with keeping the economy going and opening the schools. How is the Gauteng provincial government helping? The Gauteng MEC for education is laying out the plans to welcome back school goers....

Parts of South Africa’s Edcon set for sale to Durban-based retailer

JOHANNESBURG (Reuters) - Parts of South African retail chain Edcon are likely to be sold to private equity-backed Retailability Ltd, administrators in...

Africa to rebound from pandemic slump in 2021 but damage done: AfDB

JOHANNESBURG (Reuters) - Africa is expected to partially rebound next year from a pandemic-induced economic slump, but it could still lose nearly...
- Advertisement -